"We believed it was finally time to build this rec center and are proud to say today that when spring rolls around, it will certainly deliver for Newburgh residents." That's Town of Newburgh Supervisor Gil Piaquadio, speaking at Chadwick Lake Park in December 2025, marking the completion of a recreation center that Town Hall first floated in 1991.
Thirty-four years is a long time for a building to sit as a rendering in a filing cabinet. It went before the public again in 1998. Still nothing. It didn't reach the Town Board for real approval until 2021, and even then it took until December 12, 2025, for the ribbon to come down. If you've lived in the Town of Newburgh through any of that stretch, you've probably stopped expecting it to happen at all.
Here's the part that makes this more than a park update: the money that finally got it built didn't come from a bond referendum or a tax increase. A meaningful share of the $13 million project came from a casino three miles away, as a condition of its state gaming license.
When Resorts World Hudson Valley opened inside the Newburgh Mall in December 2022, after a $50 million renovation of the old Bon-Ton department store space, it came with a Host Community Benefit Agreement, the standard arrangement New York attaches to casino licenses so the surrounding town sees direct value, not just foot traffic and slot revenue passing through. Money from that agreement, layered with state and federal grants from Senator Charles Schumer, Representative Pat Ryan, and State Senator James Skoufis, is what finally moved Chadwick Lake's recreation center from concept to concrete.
Meghan Taylor, senior vice president of government affairs and public relations at Resorts World, framed it as a promise kept: "Resorts World Hudson Valley opened its doors with a promise to have an impact throughout Newburgh and Orange County. This new facility at Chadwick Lake Park will benefit generations to come." The same Host Community Benefit funds also help support the town's emergency response departments, so the recreation center isn't the only place the casino's licensing money shows up. It's just the most visible one, and the one every resident with kids in a youth basketball league is about to notice.
There's a tidiness to the fact that the same construction firm, Holt Construction, built both projects. The company that turned an empty department store into a casino floor is the same one that turned Chadwick Lake's old, deteriorating ice rink site into the town's newest public building. Two very different uses of the same construction crew, three miles apart on Route 300, both dated to the same few years of Town Hall decision-making.
The recreation center sits on the footprint of Chadwick Lake Park's former ice rink, a facility the town had let deteriorate rather than repair. In its place: two full-sized basketball courts, a turf soccer field, pickleball courts, and a walking track that wraps the perimeter of the court space, all under one roof at roughly 37,000 square feet. Add an exercise room, a children's room, a multi-purpose room, and new office space for the Recreation Department itself, which had been operating out of whatever space it could borrow around town.
None of this replaces what Chadwick Lake already had. The park, built as a reservoir when the town dammed Quassaick Creek in 1926, still has its three rentable pavilions, its playground, its walking trails, and boat rentals on the water (no private vessels allowed). The reservoir mostly serves as backup now that New York City's Delaware Aqueduct supplies most of the town's water, which is part of why the park could be handed over so fully to public recreation in the first place.
What's different is that the town now has an indoor answer to bad weather. Pickleball, one of the fastest-growing recreational sports nationally, needed outdoor courts here before this opened. Basketball leagues needed gym time from schools. A rained-out soccer practice meant canceling, not moving indoors. For a stretch of the calendar that runs from November through March, that's the actual difference this building makes.
The recreation center is the headline, but it landed on top of a Recreation Department that was already running a fuller calendar than most residents give it credit for. This year alone, Parks, Recreation and Conservation Commissioner Jim Presutti led a Tree ID Trail Walk around the lake, a 1.5-mile loop where participants learned to identify species along the water. The department's Alice Desmond Center for Community Enrichment has been running hands-on classes like an air-dry clay workshop with Hudson Valley Atelier, where residents leave with a wall pocket, trinket dish, or coasters they made themselves.
The town's Fourth of July Community Day had to be rescheduled this year when a forecast of 100-degree heat made an outdoor event unsafe, a reminder that even the reliable fixtures on the calendar bend to the weather Chadwick Lake now has an indoor answer for. The Memorial Day Parade still ran as it does every year. And for residents willing to leave town for an afternoon, the department has chartered trips like a Hudson River cruise aboard the Skyline Princess, with sightlines to landmarks including Stepping Stone Lighthouse, Execution Rocks Lighthouse, and Sands Point Lighthouse along the Long Island Sound.
None of this is new in the sense of being invented this year. What's new is that it now sits alongside a building the town spent three and a half decades failing to fund, which changes how residents might read the rest of the Recreation Department's programming. It's not a department scraping by on a shoestring. It's one that finally got the capital project it needed and kept the smaller, recurring stuff running the whole time it waited.
The easy story is "new gym opens at the park." The more useful one is what it reveals about how public amenities actually get funded in a town like this. For 34 years, the recreation center was a line item nobody could justify against roads, schools, and water infrastructure. It took a casino's state licensing obligation, plus targeted state and federal grants, to make the math work without asking residents to absorb it through property taxes.
That's worth knowing if you're weighing what a place offers beyond its schools and its commute. The Town of Newburgh got an indoor recreation facility not because the tax base grew enough to support it on its own, but because a specific piece of state gaming policy happened to land three miles from Chadwick Lake at the right moment. Whether that's a model the town can repeat for its next stalled project, nobody knows yet. But it's the reason your kid can play pickleball indoors in February instead of waiting for spring.
If you're weighing a move to the Town of Newburgh, or you already call it home and want a second opinion on what a specific address is really worth given everything nearby, from Chadwick Lake to the Route 300 corridor, Kathryn DeCrosta has spent 25 years reading this market street by street. Call or text to connect.
Selling is equal parts strategy and Execution - And I lead Both with precision. From positioning to negotiation, every detail is managed to deliver a refined process and a strong return.
KATHRYN DECROSTA
5031 US-9W Newburgh, NY 12550